Monday, January 10, 2011

Formula vs. Breast Milk

When I first had Otis, I was determined to only feed him breastmilk.  However, with him being in the NICU and me not having any milk come in for four days, I said it was okay to give him a little formula.  But my main source of nutrition was still to be the mama milk that came flowing in days later.  For the most part I was able to use my pumped milk, but I did supplement with formula.  At the time, Otis was so tiny and needed to gain weight and they told me his formula was higher in calorie content so he needed it.  I'm okay with that in the short term, I saw how he got when we had him home the first week.  He wasn't strong enough to nurse, he needed to be bottle fed.  Fine.

But now, weeks later, the fat man is almost six pounds and strong as can be.  I would technically be 37wks along if I were still pregnant and he'd be considered full term.  So why is it that the doctor was determined Otis needed high calorie formula to gain weight??  I had to go to the NICU to get special preemie formula they don't sell at the stores, the doctor was adamant he needed the extra calories.  I asked if he could still get breast milk and she said he really should be getting formula. 

However, me being me, I stuck to giving him the breast milk and only used the formula bottles for midnight feedings, so maybe two feedings a day were the formula.  And what do you know, he gained more than he needed to this past weekend!  So you can take your high calorie formula and shove it...

I am not against formula, I fed Ingrid the stuff for a year.  But I hate the idea of telling women they have to use it for their baby to grow.  Last time I checked breast milk was made specifically for babies. 

Facebook had a nurse in last week and I posted a picture of myself nursing Otis, with a caption saying he's a preemie and nursed right out of the NICU.  Someone posted how her friend had a preemie and was told over and over she HAD to use high calorie formula for her kid.  It just got me thinking this is probably a common occurence and that makes me sad.  I want to know exactly how much better preemies do at gaining weight with formula vs. breast milk.  Anyone know?  I'll have to look it up.

Anyway, my bub is doing fine, he's getting fatter and stronger by the day, and it's all thanks to my mama milk that I lovingly pump every four hours.  Not the stinky, staining Enfamil they sent me home with, thank you very much.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Your post makes my heart sing with joy. What an amazing mother you are. Your baby is very lucky to have you. x

arwen_tiw said...

I was almost eight weeks prem and never had a drop of formula. My mum was told that preemie babies can't latch! "Well, she is!" my mum said, and promptly ignored every single thing they told her after that. ;)

Calories aren't actually usually the biggest issue for prem babies. Antibodies, protein, and help digesting fats are at least as important. Your body produces different milk for him because he was prem - it's higher in protein and contains special enzymes that help digest fat. :)

Otis has such a strong mama, who will always fight for him. Lucky baby!

MaryAnne said...

6lbs already? Go Otis - and all that mama milk!

I have a friend who was told to feed her preemie twins the special high calorie formula. She apparently looked it up once she came out of the NICU haze, and the special ingredient was HFCS!!! Her daughters are now 5, so I don't know if that's still the case with formula - hopefully not!

MaryAnne said...

Here's an article on preemies and breastfeeding vs formula that backs up your instinct:

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/abstract/124/6/e1149

Mommy, Papa and the 'Nuts said...

Its funny, I lied to my doctor about feeding Lorenzo formula for his jaundice.... "See? Formula clears it up really quick!" Uh, huh...sure it does....
I wonder if this is why so many people fail at breastfeeding.

Chari said...

haha!!!! I LOVE your attitude about formula!!!!

I just don't get the 'formula is better' spill either and if I was in the same boat I'd lie about it...

I have a friend who is a certified lactation consultant and she nursed her preemie (her 4th child) in NICU when the nurses told her she couldn't and it wasn't the best thing. Her baby did not get one drop of formula.

Amber Liddle said...

I read up on some things and found lots of articles saying b.m. is amazing for preemies. Moms of preemies make extra protien and fat in their milk, just what a preemie needs. So...yep, we'll stick with my milk.

Beth said...

Keep up the good work Amber. I wouldn't give him formula either. Just nurse away!! That boy has always known what to do, he just had trouble staying awake to do it.